Why the Mentally Ill Belong in Treatment, Not in Jails

I, too, suffer from a mental illness. Unlike those who intentionally harm others, my condition prevents me from functioning in society. Yet, the question remains: Why should anyone with a mental illness be incarcerated?

Should I, or someone like me, be locked up merely because we are 'nuts' without having committed any crime? What crimes have the mentally ill truly committed? If jails and prisons were to be filled with those who struggle with mental health, where would society place actual criminals? For John Q. Taxpayer, it is cheaper and arguably more beneficial to let us stay in our homes while ensuring the rights and safety of those who pose a genuine threat.

The Criminal Justice System vs. Mental Health Treatment

The Criminal Justice System is not designed for rehabilitation of those with mental illnesses. Instead, it treats mental health as a crime, categorizing individuals based on their state of mind. Incarceration for mental illness is a misuse of resources that could be far more effective in providing necessary healthcare.

For instance, consider seat belt laws. If someone chooses to risk their life by not wearing a seatbelt, it is their personal choice. Similarly, drug use should be treated as a medical issue rather than a criminal one. The criminal distinction is often a means to generate revenue and control, not to address genuine public safety concerns.

Pedophilia and Cultural Norms

Our society often normalizes actions that are inherently at odds with the natural order, such as pedophilia, which is not only illegal but also a byproduct of cultural systems that reinforce power and control.

Within our societal norms, pedophilia may seem 'acceptable,' but in nature, it is virtually unknown. Animals do not attempt to engage in sexual behavior that is not aimed at reproduction. Our cultural constructs elevate these behaviors to a level of acceptance that is unhealthy, if not outright perverse.

Time for a Paradigm Shift

Instead of imprisoning individuals for their mental state, we should be focused on providing the necessary treatment and support. Society is not perfect and often fails those who need the most help. By treating those with mental illness as criminals, we undermine their ability to reintegrate into society and improve their lives.

Evolving our mindset and legal framework to prioritize rehabilitation and healthcare over punishment is crucial. Only then can we create a just society that truly values the well-being of all its members.