The Decisions of Minors: Why Doctors, Not Politicians, Make Medical Choices

There is a prevailing misconception that some people believe minors have the ability to correctly make complex medical decisions, such as starting hormone blockers or undergoing sexual transitioning. This is a serious misunderstanding that disregards the fundamental role of medical professionals in safeguarding the health and well-being of minors.

Why Medical Experts Lead

It is crucial to understand that decisions about medical interventions, much like chemotherapy, amputation, or other serious procedures, cannot be made by minors. Just like no one would expect a minor to decide on a course of treatment involving chemotherapy, amputation, allergy shots, or Adderall without medical guidance, hormone blockers and sexual transitioning are no different. These medical interventions are reserved for those who have the expertise and experience to guide the decision-making process.

The decision to pursue hormone blockers or sexual transitioning is a highly individualized and complex process. Unlike over-the-counter medications, such interventions require a comprehensive evaluation and ongoing support from a team of medical professionals. This ensures that the profound physical and psychological changes are managed responsibly and ethically.

Consent and the Role of Physicians

Minors do not have the legal capacity to fully consent to medical procedures or treatments, including hormone blockers and sexual transitioning. The involvement of a trusted healthcare provider is essential to ensure that the patient undergoes thorough evaluations and receives appropriate care. For instance, puberty blockers cannot be obtained without the involvement of a physician who has assessed the patient's condition and determined the need for such intervention.

The process of deciding on hormone blockers or sexual transitioning is a multifaceted one that involves a team of experts, including pediatricians, psychiatrists, endocrinologists, and social workers. This multidisciplinary approach ensures that the decision is made with the utmost care and attention to the child's unique needs and circumstances.

Parents' Rights and Responsibilities

Parenthood comes with significant responsibilities, including the responsibility to make informed medical decisions on behalf of their children. While parents and guardians play a critical role in the decision-making process, they must consult with medical professionals who can provide the necessary guidance and support. The involvement of parents is essential to ensure that the child's rights and best interests are protected.

The current legal framework recognizes the importance of parental consent and the role of medical professionals. It is not about politicians, cable news commentators, or any so-called experts. The laws and medical guidelines are in place to protect and support minors as they navigate their healthcare needs. These frameworks are designed to ensure that decisions are made in the best interest of the child, guided by medical expertise and supported by the appropriate resources.

Take, for instance, Klinefelter Syndrome, a genetic condition in boys that can lead to underdeveloped testes and lower testosterone levels. Testosterone therapy is often a recommended remedy for these symptoms. However, doctors generally refuse to treat boys who do not wish to undergo the therapy, as the involvement of needles might be a significant barrier for many children. The decision to start hormone blockers or other medical interventions must be made after careful consideration and consultation with medical experts.

Personal Experiences and Expertise

Many individuals who have undergone hormone blockers or sexual transitioning share their experiences, often recounting the clear understanding of their gender identity from a young age. They recall feeling different or "wrong" at various stages of adolescence, which can be a powerful argument for the belief that minors do indeed know their gender identity and the direction they want to take in their lives.

However, it is important to note that such personal experiences, while valuable, should not override the medical expertise and legal framework. The medical world recognizes the significance of these experiences and the importance of supporting minors in making informed decisions. At the same time, the role of medical professionals remains paramount in guiding and supporting these decisions.

The reality is that decisions about hormone blockers and sexual transitioning are not made in a vacuum. They involve a collaborative and multifaceted approach that includes medical evaluations, therapist consultations, and parental involvement. It is the responsibility of doctors, therapists, and families to ensure that these decisions are made with the utmost care and consideration. Trusting medical expertise is vital in this process, and it is up to lawmakers and policymakers to ensure that this expertise is respected and supported.

Ultimately, the right to make medical decisions lies with medical professionals, not politicians. The well-being of minors is the cornerstone of this approach, ensuring that they receive the best possible care and support as they navigate their healthcare needs.