The Myths and Realities of Doctor Attitudes: Dispelling the Notion of Best Doctors Having Worst Attitudes

Many people often attribute the worst attitudes of doctors to their superior competence and the pressures of managing a large patient load. However, this notion is more of a myth than a reality. In this article, we explore the subjective nature of doctor-patient relationships and the complex dynamics behind a doctor's professional behavior.

Dispelling the Myth: Best Doctors and Their Attitudes

Contrary to popular belief, some of the best doctors can have the most admirable and approachable attitudes, while others who are less competent might have a more gruff or distant demeanor. It is important to recognize that a doctor's competence and their attitude towards their patients are not directly correlated.

The truth is that whether or not a patient finds a doctor appealing is highly subjective. Patients might value a warm, approachable demeanor, while others appreciate a more professional and clinical approach. A doctor who is highly competent but has a reserved nature might still be well-liked by their patients if they provide excellent care. Conversely, a less competent doctor might seem more friendly and easier to approach.

Subjective Experiences and Attitudes

Your personal experience can greatly influence how you perceive a doctor's attitude. A doctor who you find extremely grumpy or unapproachable might be beloved by others simply because they provide outstanding care. It is important to recognize that every patient has different needs and preferences, and what works for one might not work for another.

For instance, a doctor might seem abrasive or unapproachable to some, but they might be appreciated by others for their straight talk or decisive approach. Similarly, a doctor who is overly friendly and accommodating might be viewed as inhumane or lacking in professionalism by some patients. The key is balance – finding a level of social grace and professionalism that works for the majority while still meeting the unique needs of individual patients.

The Pressure to Be Dull and Professional

There is often an expectation that doctors should be able to appeal to a wide range of patients, leading many to compromise their individuality in the interest of making themselves more relatable. However, this can lead to a homogenization of professional demeanor, stripping away the unique traits and strengths that many doctors bring to their practice.

Trying to cater to all patients can dilute a doctor's personal style and authenticity. This can result in a doctor becoming more “lowest-common-denominator-Euro-bland,” meaning they might come across as less distinctive and less engaging. While it is crucial for doctors to meet the basic standards of social grace, going beyond this level of niceness does not necessarily provide an added advantage.

The Popularity of Doctors: A Matter of Relatability and Care Quality

Some of the best doctors are also the most popular among their patients. This is often because they provide exceptional care and are relatable to their patients. For example, a highly competent GP in Hyde South Manchester was extremely popular, despite some of his more reserved mannerisms. His patients loved him, and if online ratings were a measure, he would have had perfect reviews.

Even after the shock and trauma of a major incident, such as the conviction of Harold Shipman, one of the world's most prolific confirmed serial killers, some of his patients still held a special place in their hearts. This shows that a doctor's popularity is often tied to their ability to provide excellent care, rather than just their personality.

Conclusion: The Complexities of Doctor Attitudes

The attitudes of doctors are complex and multifaceted. While some of the best doctors might have the worst attitudes, this is not a universal rule. The relationship between competence and attitude is highly subjective and can vary widely from patient to patient. What matters most is providing high-quality care that meets the unique needs and preferences of each individual patient.

It is important to remember that patience, empathy, and competence are all critical components of a good doctor. While it is understandable that a doctor's demeanor might differ from one patient to another, the underlying goal should always be to provide the best possible care and support to those in their care.