The Psychological Impact of Killing: Insights From Those Who Have Experienced It

Throughout history and across various contexts, the act of taking a human life has caused profound and multifaceted psychological shifts in those who partake in it. Whether it be in times of conflict or personal defenses, the aftermath can leave lasting imprints on an individual's psyche. This article explores the deeper psychological impacts, the adjustment processes, and the profound sense of guilt that often follows such experiences.

Psychological Cost of Killing: Personal Accounts and General Analysis

For many, the act of killing, whether in combat situations or during acts of self-defense, can lead to a significant internal conflict. The account of an individual who has experienced hand-to-hand combat and the first kill during wartime reflects the profound changes such an act can bring. "Even in wartime, combat, the first time it was hand to hand for me, kills off part of your soul. Something inside dies. You cease to care in order to survive day to day. Most recover, but not all. I'm one who didn't." This statement highlights the internal trauma that can persist long after the act has occurred.

Attitudes and Rationalizations

Those who justify their actions often have complex rationalizations. Whether these rationalizations are based on personal beliefs or external influences, they can provide a sense of validation or even religious duty. An example of such a rationalization could be attributed to biblical commandments that some individuals perceive as a divine mandate to act. A statement like "God commanded killing in the Bible, you know. We obey the Bible. I'm obeying the Bible. I'm fulfilling the will of God." can be seen in those who see their actions as a divine duty.

Long-term Effects on Individuals

The long-term psychological effects of killing can be substantial and deeply ingrained. For the individual who experienced a first-hand kill in self-defense three decades ago, the trauma still resonates today. "Even though it was self-defense and nearly 30 years ago, it has affected me tremendously, both profoundly and mentally. I sure will never kill someone, but if it was me, then I'd end up killing myself because of depression and constant uncontrollable anxiety." The profound and sometimes overwhelming anxiety and depression experienced by this individual is a common aftermath of the act of taking a life.

Contextualizing Different Motivations

Depending on the context and intent, different motivations can lead to varying psychological outcomes. For example, serial killers may experience remorse after their first killing, but the guilt may not necessarily be for the victim. Instead, it could be for the unusual emotions they may be experiencing. Similarly, soldiers often feel a sense of help when they perceive their actions as protecting the public, yet they still grapple with the emotions of taking a life. Children or spouses of abusers who kill to end their suffering may feel immense sadness, fear, and anger, while mass murderers may feel nothing at all, due to their psychopathic tendencies.

Reflecting on Future Motives

Individuals who have experienced taking a life often reflect on the aftermath and consider the future. Many, like the individual in the account, are deeply troubled by the act and would rather eradicate their own life to alleviate the emotional burden. Their actions highlight the profound sense of guilt and the difficulty in living with the knowledge of causing harm. Various pathways to dealing with these emotions include apologizing to loved ones and eventually taking their own life to end the emotional torment they carry.

Conclusion

The psychological impact of killing is a complex and multifaceted issue, with varying effects based on context, intent, and individual nature. By understanding the profound impact such actions can have, we can better support those who have experienced them and work towards prevention and healing.

Keywords