Why Do Some Answers Have Disabled Comments on Quora?

On the vast expanse of Quora, a respected QA service, the platform's mission is clear: users ask questions, and others provide insightful answers. Answers are meant to provide value to the community, foster discussion, and be a resource for future viewers. However, as the original post suggests, having disabled comments on certain answers is a choice made by the answerer, tailored to their preference and the nature of the question or the answer provided.

Understanding Quora's Platform Purpose

Quora is designed as a question and answer (QA) site, where users can pose inquiries and receive thoughtful responses from the community. Once a question has been answered and the basic exchange has occurred, some users, like the one who originally asked the question, may not feel the need to engage in further dialogue or seek recognition.

However, this doesn't negate the value of comments, which can provide additional insights, enrich the conversation, and engage the broader community. The original poster does mention that upvotes are appreciated, suggesting that while comments may not be necessary, they can still enhance the post's impact.

Why Disable Comments?

For some users, disabling comments is a strategic choice based on the nature of their answer or the potential for negative interactions. The statement "Quora is NOT a discussion forum," reflects this perspective. Here are a few reasons why:

Controversial Topics: In cases where a question or answer involves sensitive or controversial topics, the person providing the answer might disable comments to avoid potential conflicts or misinformation. Spam and Trolls: Regular instances of spam or abusive behavior may prompt an answerer to disable comments, creating a more positive experience for all users. Blocking and muting such individuals is a common practice to maintain a respectful community. Focus on Quality: A good answer can have a profound impact, either positively or negatively, on the reader. Accreditation can be shown through upvotes, thank yous, and other means instead of engaging in potentially negative comments.

Furthermore, if the answerer has to deal with a high volume of comments from individuals who cannot contribute meaningfully or are simply looking for attention, disabling comments can make the experience more enjoyable and focused. These users can choose to write their own answers or engage in the conversation elsewhere.

Case Study: Comment Disabling for Safety

A specific instance where comment disabling is essential is when a highly sensitive or controversial topic is involved. For example, if a user’s post involves very sensitive topics such as pedophilia, where inappropriate content could be shared or promoted, disabling comments is a necessary protective measure.

Users who are aware of such inappropriate behavior might be blocked or muted by the answerer. This includes common problematic behaviors such as:

Spamming: Continuous unsolicited comments that do not add value but instead seek attention or spam other users. Scamming: Attempts to gain personal information or engage in fraudulent activities through comments. Sock Puppets: Multiple accounts used to create false impressions of support or to express controversial opinions. Nazis and MAGAts: Individuals or groups who promote hate, discrimination, or offensive content.

By disabling comments in these cases, the answerer ensures that the community remains a safe and respectful space for everyone.

Conclusion

While the ability to comment is a valuable feature for enhancing the QA experience, it’s not universally necessary or desirable. Users have the right to choose whether to engage further, and in some cases, disabling comments can contribute to a more positive and respectful online environment. It’s important to recognize that comment policies, like those described, are efforts to curate a constructive and safe community experience.

Note: If you disagree with an answer, Quora encourages you to write your own answer rather than relying on comments for discussion.