Why Some Quorans Rewrite a Question Before Providing an Answer

Quora is a platform where asking and answering questions is the primary activity. However, it is not uncommon for some users to rewrite the question they're addressing before providing an answer. This practice can be puzzling for first-time users or those unfamiliar with the platform. In this article, we explore the reasons behind this behavior and the implications it has on the credibility of the answers provided.

Understanding the Practice

When responding to a question on Quora, some individuals may choose to start their answer by directly reproducing the original question. This practice ensures that the answer is clearly linked to the initial query and avoids the confusion that can arise when the question is edited after the answer is posted.

Reasons for Rewriting

The Fluidity of Questions on Quora

One major reason why some Quorans rewrite the question is the fluidity of the original query. Quora allows questions to be edited by the original poster (OP), which can lead to significant changes after an answer has been provided. By including the original question at the beginning of their response, answerers can highlight that their contribution addresses the initial query rather than a subsequent version of it.

Preventing Merges and Confusion

When questions are merged by Quora, the original question the answer is linked to becomes a header, ensuring the answer remains relevant. Some authors may include the original question in their answer to anticipate possible merges or to avoid confusion, especially if the merged question is significantly different from the original.

Dealing with Disreputable Edits

Another reason for rewriting the question is to address the possibility of vandalism. Some users may edit questions so drastically that they are no longer recognizable. Quora has recently implemented a feature allowing users to report such changes as vandalism, but the issue still remains. Rewriting the question ensures the answer remains accurate and relevant, even if the original query has been altered.

Improving Answer Quality

In some cases, the question itself may be poorly written or nonsensical. To ensure clarity and relevance, answerers may rewrite the question before providing their response. This practice not only improves the quality of the answer but also enhances the overall user experience on the platform.

Manipulating Question Interpretation

Lastly, there are instances where the answerer deliberately modifies the question to fit the answer they wish to provide. This can happen when the original question is unclear or when the answerer wants to address a specific aspect of the query, rather than the entire question. While this practice can be controversial, it might be done with the intention of providing the most useful information to the original poster.

Conclusion

The practice of rewriting a question before providing an answer on Quora can be attributed to various factors, including the dynamic nature of questions, the risk of merges and edits, and the desire to improve answer quality. While it may seem unnecessary or even manipulative to some, understanding the rationale behind this practice can help users navigate the platform more effectively and appreciate the efforts of those who contribute to its knowledge base.

Whether you're a seasoned Quora user or a new member, being aware of these practices can enhance your experience and help you engage more meaningfully with the platform's content. Remember, the goal is to provide and receive clear, relevant, and helpful information, and rewriting the question is one way to ensure this happens.

Do you have any personal experiences or opinions on this practice? Share your thoughts in the comments below!